Is Scotland’s new “Hate Crime and Public Order Act” good or bad for democracy?

Home

Polls

Staff Writer

01.04.2024

15707 views

Is the act helping, do you think it’s a good thing or a bad thing – vote yes for good, no for bad!
The legislative groundwork for the Hate Crime and Public Order Act was laid through rigorous debates, public consultations, and a thorough legislative process.
The Act’s passage was not without controversy, as it sought to tread the fine line between protecting individuals from hate crimes and preserving freedom of speech.

Prev poll Scottish Parliament Propose Assisted Dying Bill are you in favour - Yes or No Vote Now!

Next poll Should the UK ban weapons exports to Israel after 3 Brits killed in IDF strike?

1462 Votes

Select the vote option

Yes - the bill is a good

21 Votes (1.44%)

No - the bill is bad

1441 Votes (98.56%)

The votes are in the poll is now closed

Add to favorites

Share on :

Comments (234)

Piotr J Mlodzik

1 year ago

0 Likes

This new, totalitarian law will also ban critisism, freedom of opinion, freedom of belief, freedom of speech. The country I was born in came across these things a few times: WW2 and German occupation and then Communist times. I remember we weren't even allowed to talk jokes about our neighbours Russians etc because someone could get offended and our parents could end up in a jail. Previous legislation deal fine with hatred, new law will trigger true hate and resistance.

like Log in to like

Nigel Francis

1 year ago

0 Likes

Poorly thought out act , impossible to apply nor administer

like Log in to like

Barbara Simpson

1 year ago

0 Likes

Thus us a shocking law znd shoukd never have been passed

like Log in to like

Kirsty Hinshelwood

1 year ago

0 Likes

Really this is just absolutely criminal, and a complete abuse of their powers, to change the law like this to benefit a small minority because they are too easily offended by the majority's opinion. It is ludicrous just like so many other things these past few years.

like Log in to like

Martin Lambert

1 year ago

0 Likes

This weaponises all sorts of fringe groups and will be used to vilify innocent people by people filled with hate for others. It will also take up valuable Police time and form alienation in many forms but especially those unfairly accused. Free Speech you are entitled to your view. I may not like it but I respect that it's yours to say

like Log in to like

Elaine Gray

1 year ago

0 Likes

Better use of Police time could be to track real crimes! Better use of public funding could be used on a thousand different areas far more important!

like Log in to like

Susan Walker

1 year ago

0 Likes

It's a joke and makes a mockery of everyone who trusted the SNP with their previous vote.

like Log in to like

John Duff

1 year ago

0 Likes

This is a horrendous bill and needs too be abolished now.

like Log in to like

Lynne Caldwell

1 year ago

0 Likes

This bill is only going to cause more division and a complete waist of already wasted Police resources

like Log in to like

Rona Barker

1 year ago

0 Likes

No protection for true women in this bill.

like Log in to like

Kenneth Whitaker

1 year ago

0 Likes

It is a really crap law that is not needed and will put extra pressure on the cops when they least need it.

like Log in to like

Ian Howells

1 year ago

0 Likes

Everything the bill tries to cover is already covered in The Equality Bill 2010 except if course women's rights which seem to have taken second place to transexual rights. Everything this coalition Scottish govt do is designed to be devisive. Just look at the FMs rant about white people in high level jobs!

like Log in to like